Skip to main content

COP 28 is already a failure - Capitalism over Science

It hasn't been reported much by the national news here in the States; that COP 28, or the 28th meeting of the United Nations Conference of the Parties (COP) to the United Nations Climate Change Conference is currently being held in Dubai, a major oil producing country (more on that in a bit).  It is open to  "Business leaders, young people, climate scientists, Indigenous Peoples, journalists, and various other experts and stakeholders" in the future of our planet.  

It's meeting in a variety of ways current ongoing from November 30 through the 12 of December this year.  So as I'm writing this it's still ongoing and already simplifying complex and complimented decisions, creating empty promises, possibly committing or planning to commit fraud and full of controversy.

It's been a failure on the environmental front for a variety of reasons.

The idea of COP28 is a simple one according to the UN; it is to allow the major players and countries in the world to take stock of what's been accomplished so far and what course corrections need to be made in the future to fight climate change.

So when you stop laughing let's take a look at some of the things the COP 28 has accomplished so far....

  • A call for accelerating action - According to the COP's own records, while several nations are doing their part to reduce global warming to 2019 levels - we are only reducing it by 2%.  Whereas the established science is indicating that we as a planet need to be around a 43% reduction to stay under the 1.5C (that's an increase of roughly 3 F) limit, often considered the "point of no return." That increase is going to occur in our lifetimes.
  • Transforming climate finance - Honestly this is a big one and hopefully something better than what is in place now can be accomplished.   It won't be a major change, but something is always better than nothing.   Long story short the countries of the world that will be most affected by climate change are the small island countries of the Pacific and the Caribbean (some of which could literally sink under the tides of a rising ocean).   In other cases you will see climate migration as millions of people head to the cooler north seeking a more stable life.   The UAE has promised 30 Billion but the funds will be handled by worldwide investment firms, however most of the investment is in established companies and very little of the investment is going to the countries that need it the most. A lot of countries have "pledged" money but a pledge is simply a token agreement.
  • A declaration to triple Nuclear Energy - Sometimes you have to make a deal with the devil.  It's generally acknowledged that Nuclear Energy is going to help reduce our reliance on fossil fuels, but it comes with a lot of baggage.  Again this benefits the developed countries of the world, but does not address the less developed nations of the world.  Setting up nuclear power plants that would benefit developing countries is not politically possible in most cases for a variety of reasons.

 COP 28 is an acknowledgement that our world is in trouble, and that something has to be done, which is progress considering most people really didn't know about the twenty seven previous COP meetings or felt the need to report on them.


 Sadly though...none of this is being taken that seriously by our "leaders." 

The Canadian beef industry for example presented a talk on why beef should stay on the menu for most of the world's population, even questioning a large of amount of data showing that a plant based diet is not only better for the individuals health but that it reduces greenhouse gasses.   The Beef Industry of Canada however produced $38.5 Billion dollars for the country and employs some 647,000 people.    

You have to wonder how many of those 90,000 people attending this event has the best interests of humanity in mind, and how many of them want to maintain the status quo.  I understand their concern, not only would Canada's economy suffer but over 600 thousand people would lose their jobs seemingly overnight if radical change would occur.   We don't have much choice in the matter though do we?

Recently the President of COP 28 - Dubai's Sultan Al Jaber, who just happens to be an oil executive, stated that there was "no science"  that says phasing out fossil fuels is necessary to keep global warming under the critical threshold of 1.5 C.   Only there is a lot of good science that does.  Add to that leaked notes indicating that United Arab Emirates was planning on using the COP 28 to make oil and gas deals; one must wonder how serious they actually are about climate change.  

ABC News is reporting that at least 1,300 attendees at the COP are employees of fossil fuel interests.   Overall it's a small number as COP28 has some 90,000 attendee's, but this number is significant because we have to ask what they are advocating for.

 I'm not a dreamer, I'm not a fool but this business as usual stance simply is failing us.   Radical change is going to be necessary or it's going to be forced upon us.  

I'm not talking about the government forcing changes upon us but nature itself forcing radical change.  Doctors and pathologists already are expressing concern about "zombie" microbes frozen for generations is permafrost being released, and how over half of the known diseases are aggravated by global warming.  

It's been estimated that 3 million people died from COVID.  Imagine a pandemic that kills 6 million, or up to 9 million, because that is completely within the realm of possibility.

So if we can't count on our so called leaders...where that does leave the average citizen on the street?

Well we can hide our heads in the sand, accept our fate and live like there will be no tomorrow...or do what we can.

A long time ago I decided to do what I can; a blog like this serves not only as a warning but as a beacon of hope.  Planting trees or a garden, canning fruits and veggies, storing seeds, seed bombing, riding a bike to work, taking a bus, eating a plant based diet and a 1001 little things can make a difference in your community.

Because the individual does matter and a single voice can join a choir and that choir can be heard.  

Because Community does matter.  Because your family does matter.  Because little actions matter.  

I'm not going to lie, things are bad and are going to get worse...but they will get a lot worse if you do nothing.   Radical change has to begin somewhere and it needs to start now. 

Comments

What all the cool kids are reading.

Digging in the dirt

In a lot of ways I feel rejuvenated.  It's a glorious morning as I am driving down to Pittsburgh with the local radio station playing a mix of old and new that elevates my mood, the sun shining strong through the sun roof.   I am on my way to buy plants.   I have a list in my pocket and I expect that I'll be coming home with a few of them.  I had hoped to buy spicebush and maybe serviceberry , in addition to what I did end up buying.  As I talk to people there, I use the term " food forest " because that's about the closest definition to what I'm trying to do, although it's also not the best one.     What I'm more interested in doing is creating a refuge.  A place for a weary traveler in the future to stop, rest under the trees and have access to wild strawberries and blueberries (which sadly didn't take last year), apples etc.   A place of respite rather than a place that can self maintain itself over time, although I do...

When it rains - The conclusion

The month of May for what ever reason seems to be passing slowly, but the year seems to be flying by.   Suddenly we are nearing the end of the month and I'm only now getting to work on the yard.   I did go in search of an electric powered riding lawnmower, for the same reasons that I went in search of an electric car.    Both searches failed, as the local hardware, lawncare and "big box" stores simply didn't carry any electric riding mowers.  I could have ordered an electric mower off of Amazon, or similar site, and had it shipped but then I would be looking at a two week delivery timeframe, and would have exceeded t he budget that I had set for myself. The grass, though high and feeding a variety of pollinators and other insects would simply not wait much longer.  Plus ticks are always a concern in Western PA at this time of year, and one way to control them is to keep your grass cut.   I had already had a few instances of dealing with...

Why didn't Erie, PA develop into a bigger city?

          Recently I had to travel up to Erie, PA for business.   It's about an hour north of me and is a rather small city, having just under 100 thousand people living in it.   It played an important role in the founding of America,  - where it was the headquarters for Oliver Perry's flagship Niagara during the battle of Like Erie in the war of 1812 .            It was also a important shipping center, being Pennsylvania's only access to the Great Lakes which was the easiest way to trade with parts of Canada at the time as well as move goods to the cities of Detroit and Chicago, which in the mid to early 1800's were just starting to develop.  It was also directly north from Pittsburgh which was a major industrial city at that time.     Yet Erie never really grew beyond it's humble beginnings and I wondered why.   Like any good sleuth I turned to the intern...