Skip to main content

What will we do when the wheat is all gone??? The city mouse talks about bread.

Hope is the poor man's bread.

Somehow I started watching a video about "Poor Man's bread" that was bread made from various flours in the 1700's and early 1800's.  This popularity of this type of bread has waxed and waned in popularity at times when wheat production faltered for whatever reason.



The history of bread is an interesting one and their have been lots of substitutes for wheat bread throughout times of drought or diseases; or when other issues like poor soil and wheat diseases affected production.  Wheat has always been the preferred crop when it came to bread.

While wheat farming practices and yields have certainly increased since the late 1700's this most important of crops face new problems in a ever heating world.

I started to wonder....could some of these substitutes make sense in today's world?  Or better yet, what about the world of tomorrow?  What would replace wheat bread if the crops failed today?

Quick searches for things like bean bread and pea bread lead to a few interesting options, including bread that was boiled and not baked like breads are normally.  

While at the time of this writing, I'm not sure if I want to explore any of these recipes but I do find them interesting.  It just goes to show you the ingenuity of our ancestors who found a way.  If we are going to find a way out of this mess, then we have to be as creative as our ancestors were 200 years ago.

The question for me is how do you change a food culture?  Why did wheat bread, and wheat in general become such a staple crop for billions the world over?  

Is there some way to change that in today's world?  What, if anything is going to replace wheat?  Would we be willing to eat it?

Sadly lots of studies have been already done concerning global warming and wheat production.  They all tell the same story, production has been falling as temperatures rise. Depending on the study that production is between 1 - 10% of the yield for each degree of temperature.

Wheat is a staple crop for roughly 35% of the Worlds population or roughly 3 Billion people.  To think of it another way that is roughly the population of India and China combined.  Wheat is the staple crop for most of Africa and the Middle East, where nearly all of it is imported so any disaster to the wheat crop would create huge famines in a part of the world that is already racked by food security issues.

As such science has been working on gene modification and other techniques to grow heartier and more drought resistant wheat.   While I applaud these efforts, it still doesn't address the elephant in the room.  What happens if our wheat production fails?

Corn and Rice will most likely replace wheat production in the coming years but rice production actually produces roughly 10% of the world's agricultural emissions.  Rice production also results in methane gas production.  Rice is currently the fourth most grown crop in the world.

However, improved farming techniques could reduce methane production and actually aid in carbon sequestration.   American farmers using these techniques have shown methane production to have fallen by anywhere from 65 - 90% while using 38% less water.   At this time I'm not sure how that effects crop yield and research is ongoing but this work is promising.

Corn production has been under attack in the past for it's heavy use of pesticides and nitrogen based fertilizers which, to it's credit, the industry has addressed, but it is still a labor intensive crop.  However it generally does well in warming climates and can be drought resistant. 

An "ancient grain" like Amaranah has potential because they are very similar nutritionally to cereal grains like wheat and,despite its small grains, is capable of corn like production numbers.  It requires less water to grow and every part of the plant is edible.   While this plant is not generally considered a major production crop, its benefits outweigh it negatives and it's biggest hurdle to overcome is a general lack of knowledge on how to grow Amaranah and a limited availability of its seeds.    Plus a general lack of recipes where it is the star of the plate.


It's a well known fact that legumes and pulses - things like fava beans, lentils, cowpeas and chickpeas - are not only healthy and nutritious but require less fertilizer.  However here in America beans have often been seen as just a side dish, or a "poor mans" food.    

How do you change deep seated feelings about food?   How do you win hearts and minds?  

I've written about different food sources before, I've praised the lowly Dandelion and frankly a lot of climate friendly foods I've not discussed here like okra, mushrooms and sweet potatoes.  

I'm not a vegan nor am I a vegetarian but I am smart enough to know that changing my diet is one of the easiest things I can do to fight climate change.   It's also hard.  

Change is always hard but it's needed.  It is necessary. It is going to happen regardless of our feelings or politics or choices.  All we can do is try to understand it, prepare for it and do our best.  

**I'm including this link here because it's still being researched but it's an ancient technique that shows promise in grain production.  https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2023/01/ancient-farming-strategy-holds-promise-climate-resilience**

Comments

What all the cool kids are reading.

Honoring the past - Thinking more about "invasive" plant species.

 Recently I've been giving some thought to invasive species.  I had received both positive and negative feedback on the blog post concerning kudzu and recently I came across a very well hidden, and very small, wild cherry tree while doing some yard work.  Since it's against the house it would have to be removed since the root systems could damage my foundation.   A buddy of mine at work was asking if I was going to transfer it, his logic being that it was a fruiting tree that would not only attract a variety of pollinator's but that the deer would eat the bark and cherries, keeping them away from the garden (which Sue and I swore we were not going to do this year).  It occurred to me that I was going to have to do a slightly better job of identification, since black cherries are native to America , where as other types of cherries are not.  Being able to make a precise identification would be helpful.   I used to be able to identify all these tre...

A sense of time in place - traveling in Central PA

One of the first items that Sue and I bought as a couple all those years ago was a grandfather clock.  We used to snuggle under the blanket and listen to the chimes on the hour, the sound filling our house with a warmth and resonance.   That clock is nothing special, being simple in its design and technology.  It's accurate because of the beauty of physics and math...and is a lost art form in its own right. I thought a lot about time and place as we traveled this week.  I thought a lot about place.   Sue and I finally took a brief vacation recently.  Due to circumstances beyond our control, every plan we had made to get away earlier in the year came to naught.  My father became ill and ended up in the hospital which we decided to stay home "just in case."  He ended up in the hospital at least three times this past year, and I decided to spend what time I could with him. Family, after all, is what brought us back to Pennsylvania. We had p...

Maybe we need to rethink invasive species???

Hi. As the writer of the post and feel that I need to clarify something. I do not advocate the planting of invasive species. The point that I'm trying to make, and clearly didn't, is that perhaps we should be thinking about an invasive species in a different light. Apples, figs and other crops are clearly non native to America and Europe but are widely cultivated because they have use to humans as a food source, animal feed, etc. Kudzu is an edible plant and although it is clearly harmful can it be used someway by humans? It's a food source, it's been used as a cloth and is showing some use as a building material. All I'm trying to do is to create discussion on how we can use invasive plants in new ways.   It's mid April here in Western Pennsylvania and so far it's been warm and wet.  The buzz of lawnmowers fill the air as I gallivant through my back yard collecting dandelions to make some tea and bread with them.  I had always known that they w...